during: 2003

tags

API design · academia · agile · agile adoption · agile history · analysis patterns · application architecture · application integration · bad things · big data · build scripting · certification · clean code · collaboration · conference panels · conferences · continuous integration · data analytics · database · delivery · design · dictionary · distributed computing magazine · diversions · diversity · documentation · domain driven design · domain specific language · domestic · encapsulation · enterprise architecture · estimation · evolutionary design · expositional architectures · extreme programming · gadgets · ieeeSoftware · infodecks · internet culture · interviews · language feature · languageWorkbench · lean · legacy rehab · legal · metrics · microservices · microsoft · mobile · model-view-controller · noSQL · object collaboration design · parser generators · photography · podcast · popular · presentations · process theory · productivity · programming platforms · project planning · projects · recruiting · refactoring · refactoring boundary · requirements analysis · retrospective · ruby · scrum · software craftsmanship · talk videos · team environment · team organization · technical debt · technical leadership · testing · thoughtworks · tools · travel · uml · version control · web development · web services · website · writing

2014 · 2013 · 2012 · 2011 · 2010 · 2009 · 2008 · 2007 · 2006 · 2005 · 2004 · 2003 · 2002 · 2001 · 2000 · 1999 · 1998 · 1997 · 1996

All Content

OnceUponaTimeInTheWest

My friends are all geeky, so many of them were looking forward to the day in November 2003 when the extended DVD of The Two Towers came out (and among my friends the extended DVD was the only one worth having.) But for me that day marked another release that was in many ways just as important, Sergio Leone's great western finally made it onto DVD.

26 December 2003

bliki


DerivedInformation

Consider a simple example, you have a class that represents a rectangle and you want to know its height, width, and area. How do you show that the area is derivable from the height and width?

25 December 2003

bliki


ProvideServiceStub

An important thought for anyone building services for a service oriented architecture. When you build your service, also build a service stub that your clients can use to test against. Such a stub should provide canned responses to a fixed set of requests, simulate error conditions, and be runnable on a client's machine. You'll need to ensure that the stub mimics the true systems behavior properly. By providing a stub for your clients, you make it much easier for your clients to use your service; which of course means that your service is more likely to be used.

2 December 2003

bliki


TestingLanguage

I'm currently sitting in a session at XP day where Owen Rogers and Rob Styles are talking about the differences between XP's unit and acceptance tests. This triggered a thought in my mind - what should a language for writing acceptance tests be?

2 December 2003

bliki


CommandOrientedInterface

The most common style of interface to a module is to use procedures, or object methods. So if you want a module to calculate a bunch of charges for a contract, you might have a BillingService class with a method for doing the calculation, calling it like this

aBillingService.calculateCharges(aContract)

A command oriented interface would have a command class for each operation, and be called with something like this

CalculateChargeCommand.new(aContract).run()

23 November 2003

bliki


UnwantedModelingLanguage

The UML means different things to different people, which is why I find the notion of people using a different UmlMode useful. Most people I talk to are interested in UmlAsSketch and this group isn't very impressed with UML 2.

3 November 2003

bliki


C-Refactory

So far refactoring tools have appeared for a number of languages. After Smalltalk's lead, we've seen several tools for Java and a couple for C#. One language conspicuous by its absence is C++, despite appeals. All this despite the fact that the first refactoring thesis was done by Bill Opdyke, who's background is in C++.

18 October 2003

bliki


LocalVariablesInClassDiagrams

The simple answer to this is that you don't. I don't remember a case where I've seen a need to do this. Where I've seen it done, it hasn't communicated much that's useful.

6 October 2003

bliki


TechnicalDebt

You have a piece of functionality that you need to add to your system. You see two ways to do it, one is quick to do but is messy - you are sure that it will make further changes harder in the future. The other results in a cleaner design, but will take longer to put in place.

1 October 2003

bliki


DependencyAndAssociation

In general, you use an association to represent something like a field in a class. The link is always there, in that you can always ask an order for its customer. It need not actually be a field, if you are modeling from a more interface perspective, it can just indicate the presence of a method that will return the order's customer.

17 September 2003

bliki


Seedwork

In the very earliest days of Object-Orientation, the OO advocates like me put a lot of attention into arguing in favor of reuse. Early on we talked about reusing of classes. Then we discovered that reusing individual classes, while it worked in some cases, didn't work so well elsewhere. So we got into reusable frameworks, which got us part-built applications of functionality.

11 September 2003

bliki


EtymologyOfRefactoring

This question struck my mind a few times when writing the refactoring book. I knew the term was used within a fairly small community, so in order to discover the etymology of refactoring I talked to the people in that group (Ward Cunningham, Kent Beck, Bill Opdyke, John Brant, Don Roberts, Ralph Johnson...) to find what had led them to come up with the term.

10 September 2003

bliki


CurrencyAsValue

There are many common examples of ValueObject, my favorite is Money - and one closely linked to Money is currency.

26 August 2003

bliki


PleasingTheCustomer

All agile methods stress the importance of direct interaction between the developers of a system and customers who are its eventual beneficiaries. The agile manifesto said "Business people and developers must work together daily throughout the project", which is there to stress the high frequency of interaction. Extreme Programming stresses this through its practice of OnsiteCustomer.

15 August 2003

bliki


MultiplicityNotCardinality

When data modeling methods talk about relationships, they use the term cardinality to indicate how many entities may be linked together. So you might have a relationship between order and customer and say that the cardinality of the relationship is one-to-many. Or you might hear that the cardinality of customers for an order is 0-to-many.

12 August 2003

bliki


PatternsAreNothingNew

A common complaint about patterns books is that they have nothing new to tell experienced developers. (I've had a few of these recently in amazon reviews and on The Server Side, so perhaps I'm feeling sensitive at the moment.) Not just is this true, but it's the whole point of patterns.

31 July 2003

bliki


FixedPrice

Many people belive that you can't do a fixed price contract in an agile project. Since the whole point of an agile process is that you cannot predict the future, this isn't an unreasonable supposition. However this doesn't mean you can't come up with a fixed price agile contract, what it really means is that you can't come up with a fixed scope contract.

29 July 2003

bliki


HistoryIsNotBunk

History is more or less bunk

-- Henry Ford

I recently got an unhappy email from a reader of UML Distilled. It's never a good start to my day when an irate reader regrets buying, let alone reading, my words of occasional wisdom. But there was something particularly interesting about this reader's beef. His concrete complaint was about my 'unnecessary history'.

15 July 2003

bliki


The Difference between Marketecture and Tarchitecture

Luke Hohmann

When we think about software architecture, we usually think about its technical architecture. But there's also another important architecture - the one we use to communicate with the customers of the software: the marketing architecture. Neglecting this "marketecture", and its relationship with the "tarchitecture", can get development projects into a lot of trouble.

July 2003

pdf


Agiledox

My colleague Joe Walnes pointed me to a fascinatingly simple tool developed by our colleague Chris Stevenson. TextDox (part of AgileDox) is a tool to automatically generate documentation from JUnit test cases. Sounds ridiculous, but then that's what Wardish ideas are like.

23 June 2003

bliki


SecurityAndDesign

This last week I had the pleasure of wandering around Florida speaking with Dan Sandlin and David LeBlanc at a series of Microsoft architecture councils. For those who don't know David LeBlanc wrote the very popular book Writing Secure Code with Michael Howard. At each of the session I would do a talk / q&a on P of EAA (which got a JavaWorld award this week) and David would follow on security.

14 June 2003

bliki


Uml2

Last week the OMG adopted the superstructure document for UML 2. In practice this means that UML 2 is agreed on. There are numerous changes to the UML in UML 2 - it represents the biggest overhaul to the UML since the UML was originally agreed on. For general users the most obvious changes are probably:

8 June 2003

bliki


RefactoringCringely

A recent piece by Robert Cringely caused a small stir in the refactoring community recently, as he criticized refactoring. Phlip summed the response on the refactoring mailing list with an unusually restrained '...he sounds like a "skeptic" who writes reviews of books he has no intention of reading.'

3 June 2003

bliki


WhatIsaBliki

I've been watching the blog scene develop for a while, and it's impossible to not want to join in. But there are things I'm not so keen about blogs. For a start the name, as my colleague Mike Two puts it, "blog sounds like something I should pay a physician to remove". Beyond the name, however, there's the very ephemeral nature of blog postings. Short bursts of writing that might be interesting when they are read - but quickly age. I find writing too hard to want to spend it on things that disappear.

26 May 2003

bliki


FrameworkBuilding

It's a common question, and the short answer is that yes, refactoring is very useful when building a framework. But the issues involved depend on the state of life of the framework, and particularly in the approach you use to building a framework.

18 May 2003

bliki


WhatIsFailure

CHAOS report says only 34% of projects succeed.

The Standish Group's CHAOS report has been talking of billions of wasted dollars on IT projects for many years. The 34% success rate is actually a improvement over 2001's figure of 28%. But what do we really mean by 'failure'?

15 May 2003

bliki


AccessModifier

Object-oriented languages divide a program into modules called classes. Each class contains features, which consist of data (fields) and methods. (Not all languages use these terms, but they'll do for this.) Languages have various rules about what other classes can access the features of a class, these are often based on access modifiers that apply to a class.

13 May 2003

bliki


LargeAgileProjects

A common question is whether large projects can be done with agile techniques. After all many agile approaches are designed for smaller projects and the heavyweight ideas that they resist are more needed on bigger projects.

10 May 2003

bliki


Errant Architectures

Software Development magazine adapted chapter 7 (Distribution Strategies) of my book Patterns of Enterprise Application Architecture as an article in their magazine. I suspect they liked it due to its tone and the inclusion of the First Law of Distributed Object Design.

1 April 2003


Canadian Workshop on Scaling XP/Agile Methods

by Jonathan Rasmusson and Jim McDonald

As XP and other Agile methods gain popularity, questions are beginning to surface regarding how to scale XP beyond teams of 10-12 people. In mid February 2003 a workshop dedicated to the subject was held in Banff Alberta Canada. In this article we report on the keynote speeches from Ken Schwaber, and Martin Fowler, as well as other leading practitioners.

March 2003

article


Evolutionary Database Design

by Pramod Sadalage and Martin Fowler

Over the last few years we've developed a number of techniques that allow a database design to evolve as an application develops. This is a very important capability for agile methodologies. The techniques rely on applying continuous integration and automated refactoring to database development, together with a close collaboration between DBAs and application developers. The techniques work in both pre-production and released systems.

January 2003

article


When to Make a Type

Guidelines on when to make a new user defined type (or class) for values.

January 2003

pdf

PublishedInterface

Published Interface is a term I used (first in Refactoring) to refer to a class interface that's used outside the code base that it's defined in. As such it means more than public in Java and indeed even more than a non-internal public in C#. In my column for IEEE Software I argued that the distinction between published and public is actually more important than that between public and private.

26 December 2003

bliki


KeyringLaptop

A laptop on a keyring, well in many ways this can only an exaggeration, but the idea has been intriguing me recently. The catalyst was coming across Knoppix.

24 December 2003

bliki


StickyTimeline

A project timeline is a valuable thing to produce during a project retrospective. A timeline should show the various events that occurred during the project, and how they affected the project.

2 December 2003

bliki


AnemicDomainModel

This is one of those anti-patterns that's been around for quite a long time, yet seems to be having a particular spurt at the moment. I was chatting with Eric Evans on this, and we've both noticed they seem to be getting more popular. As great boosters of a proper Domain Model, this is not a good thing.

25 November 2003

bliki


HistoryOfIterativeDevelopment

Most of the clients I run into have not heard of iterative development, or consider it to be a new and relatively untried phenomenon. In contrast iterative development has been around for a long time under various names. A recent article by Craig Larman and Vic Basili in IEEE Software summarizes an effort to capture this history and gives you a good idea on the long story of successful projects that use iterative development approaches.

6 November 2003

bliki


Data Access Routines

A common part of encapsulation, particularly with object-oriented systems, is hiding data structures. Yet it's also common to expose much of this data behind data access routines. In this column I cover some guidelines for writing data access routines. However don't forget that if you can leave the data hidden, that's usually better.

November 2003

pdf


EnterpriseArchitecture

Just recently I've picked up a couple of bad reviews on Amazon for P of EAA because there is nothing in the book about enterprise architecture. Of course there's a good reason for that - the book is about enterprise application architecture, that is how to design enterprise applications. Enterprise architecture is a different topic, how to organize multiple applications in an enterprise into a coherent whole.

9 October 2003

bliki


PrinciplesOfXP

Every XP aficionado knows about the 4 values and 12 practices, but how many people know about the 15 principles? I'll confess I didn't when Kent talked about them at JAOO last week. After the talk I asked Kent about them: "were they in the White Book". "Yes", he replied, "cunningly hidden in a chapter called 'Basic Principles'".

4 October 2003

bliki


MovingAwayFromXslt

All of this site is written in simple XML documents and transformed to HTML. I find this works really well, and means I never have to worry about dealing with HTML formats. (Not that fancy layout is my style, as you can tell.) I've even written a whole book that way.

20 September 2003

bliki


PlatformIndependentMalapropism

One of the big claims about Model Driven Architecture (MDA) is that it allows you to develop a system in a Platform Independent Model (PIM) that can then be transformed into Platform Specific Models (PSM) for technologies such as .NET or Java. An alert reader should say to this: "hang on a moment, isn't the whole point of Java to be platform independent? So why would I want some platform independent technology that generates another platform independent technology?"

12 September 2003

bliki


ApplicationBoundary

One of the undecided problems of software development is deciding what the boundaries of a piece of software is. (Is a browser part of an operating system or not?) Many proponents of Service Oriented Architecture believe that applications are going away - thus future enterprise software development will be about assembling services together.

11 September 2003

bliki


CannotMeasureProductivity

We see so much emotional discussion about software process, design practices and the like. Many of these arguments are impossible to resolve because the software industry lacks the ability to measure some of the basic elements of the effectiveness of software development. In particular we have no way of reasonably measuring productivity.

29 August 2003

bliki


UseCasesAndStories

This is a common question, and not one that has a generally agreed on answer. Many people in the XP community consider stories to be a simplified form of use cases, but although I used to hold this view I see things differently now.

18 August 2003

bliki


BuildingArchitect

When people use the term 'software architect' they are using a metaphor from building construction to help people understand the architect's role.Ironically in doing this they misunderstand the actual role of a building architect.

14 August 2003

bliki


FixedLengthString

Look at most libraries that talk between application programming languages and relational databases, and you'll notice that they map the string type in the database (char or varchar) to a string type in the programming language. Simple, obvious, but perhaps it's wrong.

11 August 2003

bliki


SingingDetective

The Singing Detective is a TV series (6 one hour episodes) produced by the BBC in the 1980's. Many people, including me, consider it the finest piece of television they've ever seen. It's a complex piece, possibly one of the most original pieces of art ever made for television. As such it isn't everybody's cup of tea, but I've watched it many times. It's most noticeably associated with the writer Dennis Potter, who made many challenging television programs. It's recently become available on DVD.

30 July 2003

bliki


MultipleCanonicalModels

Scratch any large enterprise and you'll usually find some kind of group focused on enterprise-wide conceptual modeling. Most commonly this will be a data management group, occasionally they may be involved in defining enterprise-wide services. They are enterprise-wide because rather than focusing on the efforts of a single application they concentrate on integrating multiple applications.

21 July 2003

bliki


Who Needs an Architect?

What is architecture, and who exactly is an architect? These are questions that seem to get everyone very heated. So in this IEEE Software column, I let Ralph Johnson explain about architecture: with a definition that matches all others in a way that nobody agrees with. I also talk about two sub-species of architect: Architectus Reloadus and Architectus Oryzus.

July 2003

pdf


Swebok

This is the month for review of the IEEE's Software Engineering Book of Knowledge. This is an attempt to define the body of knowledge of our profession, in a way that can lay the groundwork for a licensed profession.

24 June 2003

bliki


TypedCollection

When people are starting to work with objects, particularly in a strongly typed language, a common question is whether they should have specific collection classes for different domain types. So if you have a company class which stores a collection of employees, should you use a regular collection class from your libraries, or should you create a specific EmployeeList class - a typed collection.

17 June 2003

bliki


MakingStubs

A common problem with test-enhanced designs is how to create Service Stubs in test mode while letting the real thing be there for production (and for some tests). A couple of my colleagues have shared their ideas.

10 June 2003

bliki


IncludeAndExtend

UML use case diagrams define a bunch of relationships between use cases. The two best known are include and extend. There seem to be more questions on these two relationships than on any other part of use cases, perhaps even anything in the UML.

5 June 2003

bliki


UmlMode

While I was looking at UML 2, it occurred to me that people differ about what should be in the UML because there are differing fundamental views about what the UML should be. As I thought about this, I came up with three primary classifications for thinking about the UML: UmlAsSketch, UmlAsBlueprint, and UmlAsProgrammingLanguage. (Interestingly Steve Mellor independently came up with the same classifications.)

28 May 2003

bliki


LanguageForLearningObjects

For the last couple of years the first choice language for learning about objects has been Java. There's many good reasons to use Java.

23 May 2003

bliki


AggregationAndComposition

Few things in the UML cause more consternation than aggregation and composition, in particular how they vary from regular association.

17 May 2003

bliki


ProtectedData

OO designers differ about whether you should make all your data private or whether they allow some to be public.

14 May 2003

bliki


CollectionsOnClassDiagrams

Usually you don't show the collection on the class diagram as a class. All you do is show an association between the album class and the track class. By marking the association with a * multiplicity you imply that a collection is in play.

12 May 2003

bliki


Components and the World of Chaos

Rebecca Parsons

Why chaos theory suggests that component assembly may not be as easy as it's cracked up to be.

May 2003

pdf


Patterns

My IEEE column on the valuable contributions that patterns can make to understanding software design.

March 2003

pdf


Domain Logic and SQL

Over the last couple of decades we've seen a growing gap between database-oriented software developers and in-memory application software developers. This leads to many disputes about how to use database features such as SQL and stored procedures. In this article I look at the question of whether to place business logic in SQL queries or in-memory code, considering primarily performance and maintainability based on an example of a simple, but rich SQL query.

February 2003

article


Writing with XML

For quite a while now, I've been doing most of my writing using XML - even to the point of writing my last book in XML. As I've mentioned this to people they've asked me a number of questions about my experiences, and that's been enough to prompt this little article on the whole thing.

January 2003

article